Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Weeding Project Overview

 
Collier Library is undertaking a long overdue weeding of print books.  Weeding is the process of culling a library’s print materials of selective titles that no longer serve the needs of its users.  As most of you know, today’s academic library no longer points to the print collection’s size as an indicator of quality or success.  With expanding availability of electronic materials--Collier currently offers access to over 200,000 ebooks and 19,000 online journals--collections have actually grown more rapidly than in the days of print.  In addition, today’s students work more collaboratively and require facilities that meet these needs.  As a result, it is important that Collier recognizes these trends with an eye toward spaces designed for student use and collections that mirror current curriculum.  With this in mind we will weed the existing book collection to 1) Make more room for student-centered learning facilities and 2) Ensure that print collections are optimized for relevance and currency.  To achieve this we need your input.

 We partnered with Sustainable Collections Services (SCS) to develop rules to identify items for possibly withdrawal. SCS is currently working with several top tier academic libraries such as Johns Hopkins, California State University System, and James Madison University on similar projects.  SCS extracted, compiled, and analyzed our data to develop a list of “withdrawal candidates.” This list provides a starting point for the discussion of materials eligible for withdrawal.  Data used to identify withdrawal candidates included: most recent circulation date, publication date, and the number of libraries holding the item in the US. The rules associated with each of these factors varied by subject area – for example, a more recent publication date is more important for nursing and science subjects than for history or literature books.

Starting in July Collier faculty, staff, and student workers will begin “flagging” withdrawal candidates.  We invite teaching faculty to come over and visit your call number range when flagged and provide input on whether or not a title should be withdrawn.  An email notification will be sent to the campus when each phase of flagging is complete.

This will be a 4 phase operation beginning with call number P.  The tentative timeline is:

Phase 1- Collier Main books with call numbers beginning with P
(Faculty review complete by October 31, 2012)
Phase 2—Collier Main books with call numbers beginning with A-G
(Faculty review complete by February 28, 2013)
Phase 3—Collier Main books with call numbers beginning with H-O and Q-Z
(Faculty review complete by May 31, 2013)
Phase 4—Collier Reference Collection
(Faculty review complete by October 31, 2013)






Please visit this blog often to find detailed information about the project and updates on the status of the various phases. Please direct any comments/concerns on the process to collectiondevelopment@una.edu.

Tentative Weeding Project Timeline

The following tentative timeline has been established for the Collier Library weeding project. Dates are subject to change. Use the links below Phase 1-3 to see the Library of Congress Classification Outline for the call numbers under review. This will give you an overview of the subject areas covered in the call numbers. A separate listing of the actual withdrawal candidates for each classification will also be available.
 

Faculty Review Timeline

Phase 1 – Collier Main books with call numbers beginning with P
All faculty review must be complete by October 31, 2012 

Phase 2 – Collier Main books with call numbers beginning with A-G
All faculty review must be complete by February 28, 2013 

Phase 3 – Collier Main books with call numbers H-O and Q-Z
All faculty review must be complete by May 31, 2013 Friday, August 16, 2013
Phase 4 – Collier Reference Collection
All faculty review must be complete by October 31, 2013

Detailed Timeline
July-mid August 2012
  • Flags will be put in Phase 1 withdrawal candidates.Withdrawal candidate lists will be made available on the library’s website.
Mid-August 2012 – October 31, 2012
  • Faculty may review Phase 1 books. Objections to withdrawal can be made online or on the book flag.
  • Library faculty and staff will flag Phase 2 books.
November 1, 2012 – February 28, 2013
  • Faculty may review Phase 2 books. Objections to withdrawal can be made online or on the book flag.
  • Library faculty and staff will flag Phase 3 books.
  • Library evaluation of Phase 1 recommendations will take place.  Phase 1 items to be withdrawn will be removed from the shelves.
 March 1, 2013 – May 15, 2013
  • Faculty may review Phase 3 books.  Objections to withdrawal can be made online or on the book flag.
  • Library evaluation of Phase 2 recommendations will take place.  Phase 2 items to be withdrawn will be removed from the shelves.
  • Cataloging personnel will begin processing Phase 1 withdrawals.
May 15, 2013 – August 31, 2013
  • Library evaluation of Phase 3 recommendations will take place.  Phase 3 items to be withdrawn will be removed from the shelves.
  • Library faculty and staff will flag Phase 4 books.
Mid-August 2013 – October 31, 2013
  • Cataloging personnel will begin processing Phase 2 and Phase 3 withdrawals.
  • Faculty may review Phase 4 books. Objections to withdrawal can be made online or on the book flag.
November 1,  2013 – February 28, 2014
  • Library evaluation of Phase 4 recommendations will take place.  Phase 4 items to be withdrawn will be removed from the shelves.

Examining the Collection

After analyzing our data and comparing it to sources such as WorldCat, Resources for College Libraries, and Choice Reviews, SCS was able to give us some detailed information about our circulating collection.

While the criteria below are not the exact criteria used to create our candidate lists, the chart provides an overview of some key data about our titles - circulation history, other Alabama and US holdings of items, availability in electronic book format, etc.


University of North Alabama Summary -Circulating Collection 
 Title CountItem CountPercent of Filtered Item Records
All Bib Records270,286286,073N/A
All Bib Records - Filtered196,137207,218100%
Record Counts - Circulation    
Circulation - No Historical Charges (at the title level)63,44566,31932%
No circulations in past 5 years (4/1/07 onwards)161,663170,14282%
No circulations in past 10 years (4/1/02 onwards)133,314140,18168%
Holdings Counts - WorldCat   
> 100 holdings in USA 174,662183,89689%
> 5 holdings in Alabama119,297126,43161%
< 5 holdings in USA 7037850%
0 other holdings in Alabama13,37614,5077%
Other Factors   
Publication Year before 2000167,328177,72986%
Publication Year before 1990136,430146,24271%
Hathi Trust Public Domain Match7,0078,4794%
CHOICE Reviewed34,64135,11717%
CHOICE Outstanding Academic Titles6,3047,0143%
In RCL10,70311,1765%
Other Form Ebook4,7034,8332%
Titles with at least one additional copy1,5403,6022%




Selecting Withdrawal Candidates


The library has established several sets of rules-based criteria for identifying "withdrawal candidates" to be considered for weeding. The Library of Congress Classifications and the corresponding criteria used to identify withdrawal candidates are listed below.



Class B - Philosophy, Psychology, Religion
(except BF Pscyhology - See Criteria for Q's for these items)
Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates: 
  • Titles that have not circulated since 2000
  • Titles that are at least 10 years old (based on imprint date
  • Titles held by 100 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries



Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates:
  • Titles that have never circulated
  • Titles that are at least 30 years old 
  • Titles held 200 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago 
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries


Class L - Education

Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates:
  • Titles that have not circulated since 2000
  • Titles that are at least 10 years old (based on imprint date)
  • Titles held by 100 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago 
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries


Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates:
  • Titles that have never circulated
  • Titles held by 200 or more US libraries
  • Titles that are at least 20 years old
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries 


Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates:

  • Titles that have never circulated
  • Titles that are at least 20 years old
  • Titles held by 200 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries  


(Except subclasses TR - Photography, TS - Manufactures, TT - Handicrafts. Arts and crafts,
 and TX - Home Economics. See  criteria for A for these items.)
Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates: 
  • Titles that have not circulated since 2002
  • Titles that are at least 5 years old (based on imprint date)
  • Titles held by 100 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 2 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago 
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries
 

Criteria for selecting withdrawal candidates:
  • Titles that have not circulated since 2000
  • Titles that are at least 10 years old (based on imprint date)
  • Titles held by 100 or more US libraries
  • Titles held by any 3 resource sharing partners  OR by one of our geographical peers (Athens State, UAH, and A&M)
  • Titles added to the collection more than 5 years ago 
  • Titles not reviewed in Choice
  • Titles not in Resources for College Libraries